The Ranger by, Ace Atkins
Putnam, 2011
978-0399157486
352 pages
When Army Ranger Quinn Colson journeys home to the small town of Jericho, Mississippi for the funeral of his uncle, the sheriff, he finds far more questions than answers waiting. His uncle’s death is listed as a suicide, but some think it is murder. Corruption has seized the town as the greed of commercial development has allowed drug runners and swindlers to take over. Quinn becomes embroiled in a conflict to save his uncle’s property and finds out he can trust almost nobody. It is time for the Ranger to take a stand.
The proof copy of The Ranger makes it clear that this is the beginning of a series built around the character of Quinn Colson. Atkins does a nice job of creating an environment and populating it with interesting characters. He paints a stark portrait of rural Mississippi that feels authentic. Atkins also creates some very engaging characters, but he seems so focused on Quinn that the other characters get left underdeveloped. The storytelling moves along at a good, clean pace, never slowing the story. However, the dialog seems to lurch along at times in an attempt to give it an ‘authentic voice.’ But these are small criticisms.
The herculean problem with The Ranger lies with its main character. Quinn Colson is set up as the tough as nails solder with a heart of gold. Right from the start he goes out of his way to help a lost, broke, pregnant woman on the side of the road as reinforcement to this image. However, he contradicts himself throughout the rest of the story. There is little attempt to explain why Quinn would do the things that he does. Quinn motivation for undertaking his unorthodox mission only makes sense as the retelling of every spaghetti western told since the days of black and white television - he is the good guy and he is fighting the bad guys. That’s enough, right?
Quinn refuses an offer to buy his uncle’s land because it has been in his family’s name for generations, even though he has no intention of moving back to the town and he doesn’t seem to like anyone in his family. His friends, family and even perfect strangers are never once in any kind of jeopardy until Quinn makes a point to put them there. Why? Because we can’t have a hero if there isn’t any conflict…even if he is the one creating it. But it gets worse. One moment Quinn is deep in thought about how as a platoon sergeant he had to show restraint and be a father figure to his men. To be a professional. The next moment he is gleefully wounding the bad guys with a compound bow. Yes, I said wounding! Yes, I said gleefully! I have family members who are both Army Rangers and law enforcement and I can tell you that is not something they are trained to do…or would ever do. And they certainly wouldn’t do it like this:
“Two Cracking shots. A man yelled.
Quinn smiled. Boom was having a time, having found the right spot for the deer rifle, loaded, balanced and sighted right down the path…
Quinn took a breath and steadied himself, letting the string go and zipping an arrow right into Gowrie’s shoulder blade, knocking him forward and then backwards to his knees, the AK chattering away up into the laced branches overhead.
Quinn smiled again and reached for another arrow.”
As if to emphasize the point, few moments later we get Quinn shooting a man in the groin. This might be the way somebody might dream of taking revenge on someone and attempting to scare them off, but it isn’t the way a trained solder operates, much less a veteran Army Ranger. Atkins also manages to paint everyone in law enforcement as inept or corrupt. We even get the quintessential Tombstone-esc scene with the big showdown in the middle of town where real law enforcement has run for cover and only Quinn and his buddies can come and save the day. The whole story becomes cliché and simply topples like a house of cards, complete with an unsatisfying ending.
The Ranger is built off of the grand storytelling history of the lone good guy vs. the corrupt town full of bad guys. It is a template that has provided many great stories. While the writing itself is good, the hero and his motivation are so unbelievable that the story simply falls apart.
Copyright © 2011 by Chad Aaron Sayban. All rights reserved.